OT A nice gesture but.......

[rcaf_777]

The following is a conversation between me and my wife Friday night

Wife: I PVR that movie you like
Me: Which one
Wife: The one where those high school kids fight an army invading the U.S.
Me: Red Dawn You PVR red dawn well I have that on dvd but thank you
Wife: Well can we watch it anyway it looks interesting
Me: You want to watch it with me
Wife: Yes Chris Hemsworth is in it
MeRolling my eyes) Fine it's not the not the same movie
Wife: What the difference

20 mins later

Me: And that's why this movie sucks
Wife:Can we watch the movie NOW
Me: Yes you want some popcorn
Wife: Yes hurry up its starting
Me: Meh

[Schone23666]

The following is a conversation between me and my wife Friday night

Wife: I PVR that movie you like
Me: Which one
Wife: The one where those high school kids fight an army invading the U.S.
Me: Red Dawn You PVR red dawn well I have that on dvd but thank you
Wife: Well can we watch it anyway it looks interesting
Me: You want to watch it with me
Wife: Yes Chris Hemsworth is in it
MeRolling my eyes) Fine it's not the not the same movie
Wife: What the difference

20 mins later

Me: And that's why this movie sucks
Wife:Can we watch the movie NOW
Me: Yes you want some popcorn
Wife: Yes hurry up its starting
Me: Meh

And see, this is why I prefer the single life, no offense.

And yes, I think it's already been agreed by most, the remake is utter crap. The producers should have made the "villians" the CHINESE but they had to bow and kowtow to their masters. The makers of the original film themselves admitted in a documentary that it was a very controversial film even for it's time, but they made it anyway. It seems the producers of this shitty remake lost their balls, or were that desperate to reap potential () Chinese profits.

[FPSlover]

And see, this is why I prefer the single life, no offense.

And yes, I think it's already been agreed by most, the remake is utter crap. The producers should have made the "villians" the CHINESE but they had to bow and kowtow to their masters. The makers of the original film themselves admitted in a documentary that it was a very controversial film even for it's time, but they made it anyway. It seems the producers of this shitty remake lost their balls, or were that desperate to reap potential () Chinese profits.

According to what I have read, much like the game Homefront, it was meant to be Chinese villains, but due to the potential loss of revenue from China, they made the villains into Koreans. In both cases, it would of made much more sense to have the Chinese be the antagonists.

[StainlessSteelCynic]

...but due to the potential loss of revenue from China, they made the villains into Koreans.

And therein lies the reality. As I understand it now, the film makers were not pressured by the Chinese to change it, they were simply speculating how much extra money they could make if they could sell it in China.
They felt that the potential income from China was worth the rewrite.
It was all about them speculating on the potential profit - even though it destroys the integrity of the story and believability of the movie.

[Schone23666]

And therein lies the reality. As I understand it now, the film makers were not pressured by the Chinese to change it, they were simply speculating how much extra money they could make if they could sell it in China.
They felt that the potential income from China was worth the rewrite.
It was all about them speculating on the potential profit - even though it destroys the integrity of the story and believability of the movie.

I no longer doubt your cynicism.

[StainlessSteelCynic]

I no longer doubt your cynicism.

Well the name was originally inspired by the Stainless Steel Rat stories by Harry Harrison but I couldn't just steal the name so blatantly.
And the cynic part, well you can see for yourself how that fits in!

[Cdnwolf]

Well I was stoned when I watched it and thought it was great....

[stormlion1]

I actually kind of liked it, but it should have had a different title than Red Dawn. A good war movie, but not a good remake.

[Schone23666]

Well I was stoned when I watched it and thought it was great....

I was stoned when I watched Xanadu, and I thought that was great too. Olivia Newton John was hot.

[swaghauler]

I actually kind of liked it, but it should have had a different title than Red Dawn. A good war movie, but not a good remake.

They should change the title to "Kim's wet dream."

[Targan]

Well the name was originally inspired by the Stainless Steel Rat stories by Harry Harrison but I couldn't just steal the name so blatantly.

I loved that series when I was a teenager. I loved his Deathworld novels too. RIP Harry Harrison.

[pmulcahy11b]

There are LOTS of questions women ask that cannot be answered...even by giving no answer...

[unkated]

And therein lies the reality. As I understand it now, the film makers were not pressured by the Chinese to change it, they were simply speculating how much extra money they could make if they could sell it in China.
They felt that the potential income from China was worth the rewrite.
It was all about them speculating on the potential profit - even though it destroys the integrity of the story and believability of the movie.

Perhaps they would have been better off making chinese the aggressors, and made an additional ending scene for release in China...

Where the last of the American guerillas are rounded up, admit that they were selfish to have opposed the Chinese improvement of American society, apologize for the damage they caused, and accept re-education, and end with a military parade and some good martial music.

Both audiences would have been very happy.

(I have not seen the remake. Yet.)

Uncle Ted

[Schone23666]

Perhaps they would have been better off making chinese the aggressors, and made an additional ending scene for release in China...

Where the last of the American guerillas are rounded up, admit that they were selfish to have opposed the Chinese improvement of American society, apologize for the damage they caused, and accept re-education, and end with a military parade and some good martial music.

Both audiences would have been very happy.

(I have not seen the remake. Yet.)

Uncle Ted

ROFLMAO!!!

Considering the level of nationalism the Chinese are attempting to drum up in their country lately, having an ending like that would likely go over very well with them.