Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

OT - Book (Non Fiction) Review/Recommendations Thread

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Started reading "Street Without Joy" just the other week.
    Could never find a copy in Australia and I finally gave in and bought a digital copy through Google Play.

    Also got "The Sorrow Of War" from Google Play and although it's fiction, the novel is strongly based on the author's own experience as a North Vietnamese soldier fighting in the south during the Vietnam War. Had started reading a family friend's copy some years back but only got through the first few chapters before having to give it back, so I never got to finish it.

    The author, Hong Ấu Phương, was only 13 years old when he joined the Glorious 27th Youth Brigade (mostly composed of teenagers) and was one of only ten survivors out of 500 at the wars end ten years later. He then served for another three years with a graves registration unit finding fallen comrades. Like many others, he was dismissed from the army when the government had no more use for him.
    As a side note, of the ten survivors of the Glorious 27th, six are said to have committed suicide not long after they left the North Vietnamese Army.

    He wrote the novel (under the pen name Bảo Ninh) as his graduation project for the Nguyen Du Writing School in Hanoi and although it was not officially published (as the communist Vietnamese government didn't agree with it's lack of "heroic struggle" portrayals) it was copied via roneo machine in 1991 and distributed privately through Vietnam (under the title The Destiny of Love) before being translated to English and offered to a British publishers where it received the name The Sorrow Of War.

    This title seems more apt, given that early in the novel, the protagonist Kien is searching the Forest of Screaming Souls for the remains of fallen comrades from the 27th Battalion. He is the only survivor of the 27th, destroyed in that forest except for him.

    It was important to the Vietnamese to recover their dead for burial after the war as they believed that if a person is not buried properly, their soul will wander forever. Traditional Vietnamese belief holds that Kien Muc Lien reached enlightenment as a young boy but his mother had been evil. At her death she was punished with eternal torment and so her son asked Buddha for help upon which Buddha instructed the boy in the Vu Lan ceremony (wandering souls ceremony AKA the Amnesty of Unquiet Spirits) to allow his mother's soul to find peace.

    As might be guessed, this novel had a profound impact upon me even after a few chapters because it was the first time I encountered what the aftermath of the war was like for the Vietnamese who fought on the communist side. The author seems to be reaching for catharsis as much as for understanding of what happened to his teenage life and the spiritual aspects of his search resonate strongly in his book.


    Hmm, apologies all, didn't mean for this to turn into a review of a fiction title but I really do feel this book is worth reading by anyone interested in the Vietnam War because most of what we have seen published is entirely from our sides perspective.

    Comment


    • I've read The Sorrow of War and it had a profound impact on me, too. I got the impression that it was an autobiography thinly disguised as fiction to avoid trouble with the Vietnamese authorities. Great book.
      sigpic "It is better to be feared than loved" - Nicolo Machiavelli

      Comment


      • House to House, by David Bellavia

        Wow. This is intense, as advertised in this thread. The final room-clearing fight is still rattling through my head, a day after I finished reading it.

        I was possibly most impressed by the fortification work done by the jihadis, building house-sized IEDs, bricking up doors, windows, and stairwells to channel the Americans and Iraqis, and removing stairs to limit roof access.

        Relative to T2k, I was also impressed by the massive amount of bullets shot, relative to hits recorded. It reinforces my impressions that the low number of hits/accuracy/etc. in T2k v1.0 rules (1 roll per 3 bullets, accuracy limited to 60% of skill).

        Something else struck me, maybe I missed something-- only 2 squads in a Bradley platoon
        My Twilight claim to fame: I ran "Allegheny Uprising" at Allegheny College, spring of 1988.

        Comment


        • One million steps: a Marine platoon at war by Bing West

          This is about 3rd platoon, Kilo Company, 3/5 Marines, during their Oct 2010-Mar 2011 deployment to Sangin in Helmand Province, Afghanistan. The reinforced platoon deployed to a patrol base separate from their parent company. They sent out two or three squad patrols per day to harass the Taliban. (They soon received two squads of reservists to hold down their patrol base, and there was a platoon of Afghans there, too.) Snipers, mortars, and engineers were attached, rounding the platoon up to 50 members.

          Strong leadership, esprit de corps and cohesion are the themes that run through the whole account. The Marines patrolled daily, pushing back the Taliban despite IEDs and ambushes. In retrospect, I am surprised to not see bombardment by rockets or mortars, as one reads about in similar positions in Iraq or Vietnam. Their post seemed to be relatively untouched.

          West is a Marine veteran of the Vietnam War, author of several books, including The Village, which detailed the Combined Action Platoon concept as it developed during that war.

          West has harsh words for SecDef Gates and Pres. Obama, who made noises about the surge, but put a short time limit on the war. Generals McChrystal and Petraeus get praise for understanding how a counter-insurgency campaign needed to be fought, and mild criticism for not recognizing (publicly) that Afghanistan and especially Helmand were too broken for such a system to work, and for accepting a too-low force level. The Marine leadership (division, brigade, regiment) he praises for seeing that the province was too far gone for hearts and minds, it needed clearing of Taliban pure and simple. The Marines' ability to create cohesive and experienced combat teams and leaders is the real praise from the author, as well as the dedication of the individual grunts.

          It read very well to me, I had trouble putting it down and burned through it in about 3 days. I've liked West's other books, I think I've read all but 1 or 2 of his works by now.
          My Twilight claim to fame: I ran "Allegheny Uprising" at Allegheny College, spring of 1988.

          Comment


          • Thanks for the recommendation, Admiral. That one slipped by me. I've read The Village and West's book about the Marines' part in the Battle[s] of Fallujah, No True Glory, and liked them both.
            Author of Twilight 2000 adventure modules, Rook's Gambit and The Poisoned Chalice, the campaign sourcebook, Korean Peninsula, the gear-book, Baltic Boats, and the co-author of Tara Romaneasca, a campaign sourcebook for Romania, all available for purchase on DriveThruRPG:

            https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product...--Rooks-Gambit
            https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product...ula-Sourcebook
            https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product...nia-Sourcebook
            https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product...liate_id=61048
            https://preview.drivethrurpg.com/en/...-waters-module

            Comment


            • Here are last ten books that I have read:
              1. Sir Brian Horrocks Corps Commander
              2. A Soldier Speaks (Public Papers and Speeches of General of the Army Douglas MacArthur)
              3. Field Book for Canadian Scouting
              4. Europe without Defense
              5. From the Shadows: The Ultimate Insider's Story of Five Presidents and How They Won the Cold War
              6. Champagne Navy, Canada's Small Boat Raiders of the Second
                World War
              7. Basic Rescue Skills
              8. Trump-Style Negotiation: Powerful Strategies and Tactics for Mastering Every Deal
              9. Duffy's Regiment: A History of the Hastings and Prince Edward Regiment
              10. Emily Post on Entertaining
              "You're damn right, I'm gonna be pissed off! I bought that pig at Pink Floyd's yard sale!"

              Comment


              • I also snagged Daniel Bolger's "Why we lost"-- he opens with stating that along with other US Army generals, he shares responsibility for the losses in Iraq and Afghanistan. I'm looking forward to it, I have enjoyed everything of his that I read before.
                My Twilight claim to fame: I ran "Allegheny Uprising" at Allegheny College, spring of 1988.

                Comment


                • Shock effect: American snipers in the war on terror

                  Really only covers three separate areas in Iraq. One is back-to-back tours by SEAL team snipers in Ramadi, 2006; another is Marine snipers in Anbar province, 2004, and the last is Oregon NG scout-snipers in Baghdad, 2004, during the Sadr uprising then. The last one was the most intriguing to me, you can find plenty of books on SEAL and Marine snipers, I thought.

                  One of the authors is an Oregon journalist who embedded with the 2-162 Infantry, the other is a Marine gunnery sergeant, and most of the 2nd section is all his recollections, including some Somalia stories for completion.

                  Good reading, a fair description of sniper techniques, and three good looks at urban warfare from above street level.
                  My Twilight claim to fame: I ran "Allegheny Uprising" at Allegheny College, spring of 1988.

                  Comment


                  • The great gamble: the Soviet war in Afghanistan by Gregory Feifer

                    This work uses a fair number of interviews with Soviets, both soldiers and officers, mostly paratroopers and pilots. It served to remind me how brutal and ugly the Soviet army on campaign could be. Afghans are killed left and right, and looting is rampant. Also, how crappy Soviet logistics were: the looting was largely of consumer goods that couldn't be bought in the USSR, and of food or warm clothing that the soldiers couldn't get at all. The Soviet conscripts were terrorized and beaten down by their senior privates, not the sergeants. The Afghans' loyalty was as suspect and pliable that we have heard from the American war in that same country.

                    The Soviet (non)decision to intervene, as well as the Afghan disintegration that led to it, seemed to take a long time to read, while once the shooting starts, the interviews with veterans made this a great read.

                    Irony: Najibullah's government that was left behind when the Soviets finally pulled out in early 1989, no one expected his government to survive. It outlasted the Soviet Union. By only a few months, really.

                    What struck me in relation to T2k: the Soviet Army we see here is really pretty crappy. Something had to have changed (in timeline) to make the Soviets such a power in 1995-1999.
                    My Twilight claim to fame: I ran "Allegheny Uprising" at Allegheny College, spring of 1988.

                    Comment


                    • Ashley's war

                      Ashley's war: the untold story of a team of women soldiers on the special ops battlefield / Gayle Tzemach Lemmon

                      This was really well-written, in that I had trouble putting it down.

                      The book follows a group of women (already in the Army) who were among the first to compete to be on Cultural Support Teams, women who accompanied spec-ops raids in Afghanistan for intelligence & security tasks. Since women in Afghan culture need to be kept separate and safe from non-family men, American/Western troops would anger the locals by searching or interrogating any women they found, and usually not get any information. By bringing women along to calm the Afghan women, keep them safe from the raiders or the Taliban during a raid, and ask them questions without the eyes of men on them, they could ease tensions and collect information.

                      From about 2010, Joint Special Operations Command started pushing for such women "enablers", and got a lot of volunteers-- Army women who wanted to do more than sit at desks. They ran them through a quick training course in both Ranger/SF operations, and Afghan culture. (Language was an unfortunate shortfall, so female interpreters who could keep up with the Rangers-- really rare-- had to be picked up once they got there.) The women they got were the ones who were already very physically fit, able to beat the men's PT requirements and very motivated to do something active.

                      The book follows the "plank-owners" of the CSTs to Afghanistan in 2011, with interviews from many of the participants. Ashley of the title is 1LT Ashley I. Stumpf-White, who was killed by an IED in 2011, so far the only woman lost from the CSTs. The writer spends 2 chapters with her family and husband (active-duty artillery officer), as well as the other CST members and an interpreter in the aftermath of her death. I was very impressed with not just the Army's reaching out to the family, but the Rangers-- both in Afghanistan and in the States-- taking over. They didn't write her off as "not one of us" or "just an enabler", but embraced her as a Ranger.

                      T2k value It's something to consider in interrogating locals (especially in the Middle East), that women might more likely talk to non-threatening women, rather than foreign men.
                      Last edited by Adm.Lee; 12-07-2015, 07:31 PM.
                      My Twilight claim to fame: I ran "Allegheny Uprising" at Allegheny College, spring of 1988.

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by headquarters View Post
                        The unknown soldier by V$in Linna
                        With the new translation to English, here is a chance to read about the Continuation War from 1941-44, written from the point of view of a machinegun company in the Finnish Army. While some characters are fictional and others are a combination of several real personnel, there are some actual individual soldiers (under different names), who servee during the war in the said company. It's also a good description of how many Finns viewed the war.
                        "Listen to me, nugget, and listen good. Don't go poppin' your head out like that, unless you want it shot off. And if you do get it shot off, make sure you're dead, because if you ain't, guess who's gotta drag your sorry ass off the field? Were short on everything, so the only painkiller I have comes in 9mm doses. Now get the hell out of my foxhole!" - an unknown medic somewhere, 2013.

                        Comment


                        • As some of you already know, I've been collecting technical specifications on various equipment and weapons since getting back into Twilight2000. I was dismayed at the lack of detailed information on weapons like back blast, travel/flight speed and minimum arming distance. I found a book published by Osprey about the RPG that has a great deal of information in it. Gordon L. Rottman wrote The Rocket Propelled Grenade and it is full of little gems that will help you "flesh out" the RPGs in your game. There is the occasional mistake in the book, like the editor accidentally putting the stats for the RPG-2 in the RPG-7's chart, but the book is packed with useful information. I have had experience actually firing an RPG-7 in Africa (during Restore Hope) and again when I fired a Chinese Type 69 while working with a security detail that traveled to Afghanistan. Mr. Rottman's experience with the weapon mirror my own. Check out the book at Osprey Publishing.

                          Comment


                          • My last read books:

                            Kill or Get Killed by Rex Applegate
                            A Rifleman Went to War by Herbert McBride
                            Men Against Tanks by John Weeks
                            How to Make War by James Dunnigan
                            Hatcher's Notebook by Julian Hatcher

                            Comment


                            • I need to buy a copy of "How to Make War", I've read the library copy so many times. Jim Dunnigan was "the Grand Old Man" of wargame designers, and that book is an excellent introduction to the subject.

                              Comment


                              • Back to Life

                                I just had to add one or two;
                                To Hell and Back- Audie Murphy the reason I went in the Army.
                                The Longest Day Book not the movie (not bad Movie)
                                The Red badge Of Courage simple short and classic the writer knew what courage was /is
                                Pork Chop Hill again Book Not movie. I am so glad I did not fight in the frozen wasteland.
                                Any WEB Griffin Book
                                Lees lieutenants
                                Tis better to do than to do not.
                                Tis better to act than react.
                                Tis better to have a battery of 105's than not.
                                Tis better to see them afor they see you.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X